The Orioles Trade That Keeps On Giving

By Stan "The Fan" Charles

The Orioles are 2-0 during this current homestand, during which they have three games versus Seattle, four versus Kansas City and three versus Boston. As they begin play Wednesday, in the finale against the Mariners, the O's have chopped off 5.5 games out of what once was a 10-game Yankees lead.

Although most of the focus is, rightly so, on the key members of the Birds' baseball management, namely general manager Dan Duquette and field manager Buck Showalter, let's tip the cap to Duquette's predecessor, Andy MacPhail.

If you don't think MacPhail deserves much of the credit, ask the folks in Seattle and then think about it some more. The Mariners must cringe every time they have to look the Orioles in the eyes and have a former Mariner or a player with a modest degree of separation from the trade that started the Orioles' rebuilding in the offseason between 2007 and 2008, which was MacPhail's first offseason with the Birds.

MacPhail took then-Mariners GM Bill Bavasi to the cleaners and pretty much got him fired by dumping problem child Erik Bedard on the unsuspecting M's, and received in return center fielder Adam Jones and pitchers Chris Tillman, George Sherrill, Tony Butler and Kam Mickolio.


That’s not too shabby of a haul for Bedard, who had amassed a grand total of 40 wins during his five seasons with the Orioles, while losing 34 times. Since he arrived in Seattle, and including a missed 2010 season, a short stop in Boston last season and his less-than-stellar 6-12 mark this year in Pittsburgh, Bedard is 22-28 during the 4.5 seasons since he left the nest. 

The now-33-year-old lefty is a career .500 pitcher (62-62). In return, came Adam Jones, who has been a Gold Glove defender and a two-time American League All-Star. George Sherrill, a left-handed reliever who became the O's closer during his first season, was an All-Star on his way to a run of 51 saves during his 1.5 seasons in Baltimore.

Also in the deal was a tall, lanky right-handed pitcher who was just 19 at the time. Tillman has been a work in progress, at times looking as if he might squander his talent. Now 24, Tillman looks as if he may have figured some stuff out, to the point that he could really become a difference maker for the Orioles.

MacPhail saw that Sherrill was bought low, and he sold him high, in obtaining the hoped-for third baseman of the future, Josh Bell, and right-handed pitcher Steve Johnson from the Dodgers at the July 31 deadline in 2009.

Bell, while still in the big leagues with the Arizona Diamondbacks, has pretty much been a bust, but the Orioles have stayed the course with Johnson, the son of former big leaguer Dave Johnson, now a MASN analyst.

Johnson made his big league debut about three weeks ago, and tonight will make his first big-league start. On hand will be his proud father and mother, who will have smiles from ear to ear.

During this three-game series against the Mariners, Tillman dominated and won during the first game, Adam Jones drove in the game-winning run in the 14th inning last night and now the Orioles are poised to go for the sweep with Johnson.

The Johnsons may have the widest smiles at the start of the game tonight, but by the end of it, MacPhail -- wherever he resides these days -- may outsmile the Johnsons, for he made the trade that just keeps on giving to the Orioles.

Posted Aug. 8, 2012




google
stumbleupon
delicious
reddit
myspace
digg
 


Comments:
MacPhail's trades of lesser import is somewhere at the bottom of Page One on his list of problems.

There are players acquired who could have been turned over for something when they were doing well. The list starts but doesn't end with Scott and Wigginton. They left for nothing in return. This is criminal on a team afraid of a top player's salary.

The free agent list is an exercize of bottom-feeding futility.

Player development took a four-year pass.

Tejada and Bedard were like Ferrari's on eBay. The highest bidder wins. MacPhail inherited those two. Big yawn.

O's fans are lucky. MacPhail didn't want Showalter but got him. Angelos wanted MacPhail but got Duquette.

Yippee!
Posted by: Mr Bad Example @ 1:06 PM on 8.09.2012    [Add Your Comment]    [report abuse]

I will give MacPhail credit for Hardy. That's it. The rest of his "accomplishments" is just padding the resume if some other dope wants to hire him.

The real no credit given where credit is due story is how Duquette should (but doesn't) get more credit for the Red Sox end of their 86-year drought.
Posted by: Mr Bad Example @ 1:06 PM on 8.09.2012    [Add Your Comment]    [report abuse]

Steve and MrBad:

You guys are flat out wrong...MacPhail made several trades of smaller import that didn't work out, true.

Ed Wade in HOuston, Billy Bavasi in Seattle and Bill Smith in Minnesota are all gone from their jobs.

MacPhail picked his talent return in trades very well. He didn't grind at making his team better in the myriad of ways Duquette has and will continue to do so.
Posted by: stanthefan @ 11:55 AM on 8.09.2012    [Add Your Comment]    [report abuse]

As far as Bedard and Tejada were concerned, they were cancers to the team and had to go. MacPhail in my eyes was nothing more than a Angelos puppet and did what he was told, so glad he is gone.
Posted by: Steve from Sandpoint @ 9:34 AM on 8.09.2012    [Add Your Comment]    [report abuse]

Bedard was six games over .500 for a team that was 66 games under 2004-07. He was coming off a 13-5 year for a 69-93 team at age 28. Of course, MacPhail got a lot of return. Anyone could.

Tillman and Johnson are (hopefully) developing under Duquette's staff. They, like a long, long list of others did not develop under MacPhail. It was Duquette who got people on the Oriole mound so the rushed youngsters could develop properly.

Bedard and Tejada were players MacPhail inherited. He got good deals on them. Big deal. Anyone could.

Tip your cap if you want. I'd rather tip the cabby who drove him out of town.
Posted by: Mr Bad Example @ 4:44 AM on 8.09.2012    [Add Your Comment]    [report abuse]

Post a Comment:
Existing users login below:
Username:
Password:
 
Forgot Password? | Click here to create an account.





Baseball
Orioles Report 
Stan's MLB Power Rankings

Football
Ravens Report 
• Ravens Schedule | Photos

In Print
Boog Powell: Meat Of The Order 
• Complete May Issue

More 
• The Food Fan Dining Blog  
The Latest Online Content    

 

Sign Up For PressBox's Free Weekly Newsletter
Email:



  Email This
  Print This
  Text Size
Designed and Hosted by Mission Media